Note: This post has been amended (see the end) to include information requested by an overwhelming number of the readers. Thanks for your interest!
I am frequently asked, "What can I do to improve my chances of getting hired as a research analyst?" Beyond the obvious — become a CFA charterholder — there are a number of other steps that aspiring analysts may take.
Making the Intangible Tangible
What an aspiring analyst has to offer to an employer are largely abstract- and creative-thinking skills. These skills are intangible and difficult for recruiters to assess. This is one reason why firms in finance tend to recruit from the same schools decade after decade: rigor of the curriculum and reliably high quality candidates. This is also why those without experience in the investment industry find it hard to get hired for research analyst positions. That is, in the absence of other evidence, firms hire what they think they can depend on — that is, what is tangible: your education and your experience.
But do not despair if you have not gone to your country's top educational institution or if you have no experience! I went to the University of Colorado (not a top school for finance recruiters) and had very little experience when I was hired as a research analyst at one of the largest and best-known US money managers.
What employers really want is for your intangible skills to be made tangible. This realization empowers you tremendously, because with this framework, you can focus on providing concrete evidence that you have the skills necessary for being an effective analyst. When I began my career I created a personal website that included: examples of my own personal research analysis on companies; book reviews of economics, finance, and investment texts that demonstrated my ability to think critically about information; and an extended version of my CV (i.e., greater than the orthodox one-page maximum), so human resources departments could see if I had what it took to be a research analyst.
By engaging in these activities it will also sharpen your own skill set. For example, when I created my own research reports — which I highly encourage you to do — I used only primary data sources, such as company annual reports. I also did all of my own calculations for things like future gross domestic product (GDP), the future shape of the yield curve, and the cost of capital.
Recognize that your opinion matters. Companies will be hiring you for your opinion as much as for your skill set. They hire you with the expectation that you will take responsibility for your choices. So, if you choose to make your intangible skills tangible by creating your own research reports then you must track how your investment recommendations do by noting the prices of assets on the day that you recommended them for purchase and then track how they perform over time. You must be honest with yourself, otherwise you won't learn anything. This is more for you than for your future employer. (Though it certainly wouldn't look good for you to get caught fudging the numbers in even a theoretical exercise.) Markets provide a valuable feedback mechanism for assessing your skill set. The beautiful and terrifying thing about investment management is that the results of your performance are measured objectively. You either did well for people or you did not. So, if you are not doing very well, then you need to identify where your analysis broke down, and then strive to improve.
I have a friend who took a similar approach as me to getting work. He sent his research reports to investment firms every single month for two years and eventually got a job interview. By doing this process he taught himself to be an analyst.
Look for a Mentor
Across the globe, CFA Institute has scores of local societies, which are made up of many generous individuals, many of whom may be willing to guide your career track. If that does not appeal, then contact money managers whose process is in alignment with your own. You may be intimidated, but the worst they can say is "no." In any case, any possible anxiety you experience in approaching investment heroes is good practice for the anxiety you may experience in approaching management of prospective businesses, some of whom may include the likes of Rupert Murdoch or Li Ka-Shing.
Analysis Is Probably Not What You Think It Is
Most analysts — the aspiring and the experienced — think that investing is about facts, models, mathematics, and analysis. Yet, as I discuss extensively in my own book, The Intuitive Investor, there is no such thing as a future fact. Facts, by definition, are things that occurred in the past. Yet investing results unfold in the future. What this means is that investing is as much a creative and intuitive process as it is an analytical process. To be a well-rounded and experienced candidate you need to be able to think in a balanced fashion — that is, both analytically and creatively. Therefore, engage in activities that enhance your creativity, too. For me, I am an active meditator, as well as an artist. Your success as an analyst will depend on your ability to synthesize information and to see things no one else is seeing. After all, by definition, if you want to earn returns that no one else is earning, you have to do things that no one else is doing.
Stock Your Mental Toolkit
Another tip is to read, read, read, read. Read investment texts. Read texts on geopolitics. Read texts on mergers and acquisitions. Read economic texts. Read anything that sparks your curiosity, even fiction (potent advice from Tom Brakke, CFA). And most of all, read the news, from many sources every single day, and begin to develop an opinion about the news and how it affects different countries, industries, businesses, and individuals. The most important skill for any investor is: understanding information. He who understands information the best does better, and he who understands information the best and acts decisively on that information wins the day. When I was an aspiring analyst if I encountered a piece of news I did not understand, I would read not just the article in question, but also an entire academic paper or book on the subject. I did this day after day, month after month, and year after year until my mental mosaic became large.
So let your ignorance guide you. What you do not know and understand should inform what you try and learn next.
Introspection
Spend some time figuring out who you are as an analyst. This is critically important. Why? If your natural strengths as a thinker make you a good trader, then you will be very frustrated working at a deep value, long-term focused money management firm. Likewise, if your character is more in line with a long-term, deliberate process, then you will likely be frustrated at a high-frequency trading (HFT) shop. You want to know yourself so that you can make an informed decision about where you want to work, about what type of analysis works in accord with your mind, and about where to spend huge parts of your life.
Furthermore, your introspective process will allow you to take an inventory of your innate strengths and weaknesses — and we all have both. You want to develop skills that accentuate your existing talents and skills that compensate for your shortcomings, too.
Be Patient
Expect this entire process to take a lot of time. From the time I first had the idea to become a research analyst to the time I got hired doing the work I wanted to do, it took me five years. For some people it is a much shorter process. But then, having done all of the work I described above, once hired, I was promoted to portfolio manager in two short years and was fortunate enough (and maybe skilled enough) to have retired at age 35.
Best wishes for success!
If you liked this post, don't forget to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.
Update: Many of you in the comments section have requested a link to an example research report. When I began my career I got a copy of a brokerage report from my local market and then used it as the basis for my own report. I am going to point those interested in what a research report looks like to Zacks.com.
All posts are the opinion of the author. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute or the author’s employer.
Image credit: ©Getty Images/TommL
Professional Learning for CFA Institute Members
CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report professional learning (PL) credits earned, including content on Enterprising Investor. Members can record credits easily using their online PL tracker.
If you liked this post, don’t forget to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.
All posts are the opinion of the author. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute or the author’s employer. Image credit: ©Getty Images / Ascent / PKS Media Inc.
Professional Learning for CFA Institute Members
CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report professional learning (PL) credits earned, including content on Enterprising Investor. Members can record credits easily using their online PL tracker.
410 Comments
Hi Jason,
I greatly appreciate your efforts. I just joined a Venture Capitalist firm as a Research Analyst and after reading your article many things just came into perspective and I am inclined to redefine and reshape my future plans.
Thank you for sharing your invaluable knowledge and experience. I wish you many successes in the time to come.
Happy Hunting!
Arsalan Ahmed
Hello Arsalan Ahmed!
I hope that the story I described above helps you in your future endeavors. I am certain that our audience appreciates you having shared your story.
Thank you for reaching out!
Jason
Hi Jason,
In my earlier comment I said that you helped me put a perspective on certain things. I am writing this comment to share my experiences after that.
Problems I Was Facing --- How I Got Them Fixed
Mediocre Presentations --- Took an online course on MS PowerPoint and read few hundred good articles with key terms "preparing financial presentation for dummies".
Poor Verbiage in Analyses --- I started teaching an intermediate course on "financial planning for entrepreneurs" during the weekends at a community center; it greatly helped because I had to explain different financial "numbers" and "formulae" at a very rudimentary level. This exercise took care of my fundamental concepts and I am now gulping two or three different reports from various NBFIs on a daily basis to shorten my absorption period.
Lack of Recognition in the market --- I created an informal weekly newsletter highlighting different areas of opportunities/problems; now at least people in my company know my name. And a few senior partners are providing me with invaluable feedback (stating that "at least you are trying").
I still have couple of things on which I am currently working on; I'll try to provide an update if I get any success.
I know I am still at the base of that vertical curve which will need many months of practice and even more tiring nights; which will be spent studying. But I know now that "every problem" has a "possible solution" and the more "problems" I manage to solve the more "competent" I would become.
Happy Hunting!
Arsalan Ahmed
Hello Arsalan Ahmed!
What a great testimonial about the amount of hard work and smart work it takes to get better and more competitive as a human being. Thank you for sharing your story with everyone.
Guiding criteria for me were always: "what don't I know" and, "would I hire me?"
Indeed, happy hunting!
Jason
Hi Jason,
It has been long 24 days since I posted back and I am shell-shocked at how much I didn't know back then. I am continuing with my previous regime of pouring, coding and storing knowledge in my memory bank and I can clearly see abstract concepts shape up in my mind. I just understood why you refer to yourself as "an active meditator and an artist".
I just wished you could have somehow stuffed few "people management" philosophies in your main article. I am realizing that my previous perspective regarding "finance is all about number crunching" is completely wrong. I guess I have to take up some Sales or Marketing Management classes as I genuinely lack in that arena. I am quite ashamed to it admit it that none of our teachers/professors told us this, consequently I just assumed that "sales management is for sales people" so I slept through those classes. Now I have to make up for that lost time as well as missed opportunities. I would highly appreciate your input on this.
Best Regards,
Arsalan Ahmed
On a personal note: I might sound like a total "groupie" for saying this, but I really appreciate you taking time out from your busy life to write this piece. It helped me closing the bridge between being a student and a professional (still on an amateur level, but trying to improve) , with much ease and convenience. For that I am truly thankful. Cheers!
Hello again Arsalan Ahmed!
[Note: These words are in reply to the comment below. WordPress would not let me reply directly to Arsalan Ahmed.]
Wow, that is perhaps the best feedback I have ever received for something that I have written. Thanks to you for taking the time out of YOUR busy life to share your thoughts and experiences. You words are meaningful to me : )
I am beyond pleased that the interconnections between things are starting to "shape up in [your] mind." This is fantastic to hear!
As for your concern that "none of our teachers/professors told us [that investment management is just as much about soft skills]: One of the motivations for me writing the post was because massive overemphasis on number crunching in the investment business. I have been fortunate to observe several great investors at work and their alpha has come from their soft skills.
As for your question about what additional information to read to get a soft skills perspective. I just wrote another blog post that is sort of a follow up to this one about what non-financial books to read to help you be a better financial professional. In there I recommended Schermerhorn, et. al.'s "Basic Organizational Behavior" as a comprehensive resources.
Feel free to connect with me further.
With smiles!
Jason
Hi Jason,
It has been over 3 years since I posted the last comments; I do however re-visit the page sometimes when my personal compass needs some re-tuning.
I am again writing to share my experiences.
Problems I Was Facing — How I Got Them Fixed
Improving Soft/People Skills - I ventured-off from the VC/PE sector to join a mid-tier bank (in the complaint management division) where I had to deal with dissatisfied customers most of the time. Plus, I got to learn all about the banking products and services, and I was briefly introduced to all the various aspects of a banking company.
Returning Back to Core Financial Industry - After spending a year and a half in customer services, I joined an investment banking outfit (as Associate, Syndications and Debt Capital Markets Division) of another mid-tier bank. That transition required a pay-cut from the existing salary and enormous amount of hardwork to earn a job confirmation and acceptance within the division.
Lack of Recognition - I was assigned as a transaction support in few syndicated financing transactions. That provided a chance to learn the transaction and market dynamics, and routinely coordinate with the local syndicates/consortiums as well as the lenders' technical/legal advisors. With the help of some very helpful colleagues, my teams were able to tread the waters on it own, leading to the successful financial close of such transactions. Consequently, I have good working relations with the syndicate banks' working teams. Later on, the experience as a transaction support enabled me to take lead on a few syndicated financing transactions of my own which will further add value to my future growth.
Self/Skill Development - Till date I am rigorously following the old routing of "pouring, coding and storing knowledge in my memory bank" which has enabled me to work on making client pitches, creating structures for proposed/potential transactions, creating/analyzing detailed financial models to check projects' viability, review of transaction documents (both the project related as well as financing agreements), etc.
At present, all the theoretical knowledge and the hands-on experience is helping in shape up the abstract concepts rather nicely.
Last, but not least, I would like to thank you for the "Guiding criteria ... “what don’t I know” and, “would I hire me?”'. This one line has kept my compass pointing correctly and has driven me to work beyond my capacity. (many thanks for this.)
Best regards,
-Arsalan
Hello Arsalan,
What an amazing thing you have done in providing an update on your progress. Congratulations to you are in order for all of the efforts you have made.
Continued best wishes for your success!
Jason
As-Salamu-alikum ...... Sir
Hope you are fine.... I m Asad from Pakistan.
I ve done MBA in finance in 2016.. I m very interested in financial analysis studies.. .
but I ve no guidance here... soo I need your enlightened advice..
My email address is [email protected]
Hello Asad,
Thank you for your question. My advice is to begin reading books about investment analysis. Do this to identify the approaches and methods that resonate with your mind, and the way you see the world. Once you have identified the approach then you need to practice it. Usually this means by engaging in analysis yourself, and as I advise in this article. Once you have practiced the approach over time, then you can publish your research and share it with employers. This allows you to show them that you have the skill needed to be an investment professional.
If you have other questions, feel free to ask. Also review the extended comments of this article because almost every question that someone could ask has been asked, and I have answered it.
Best wishes for success!
Jason