Bridge over ocean
20 December 2016 Multimedia

The Prospects for Active Management, with Morningstar’s Jeff Ptak

  1. Jeff Ptak
  2. Patrick O’Shaughnessy

Welcome to Patrick O’Shaughnessy's podcast series, Invest Like the Best.

Joining me on the podcast this week is Jeff Ptak, head of global manager research at Morningstar.  Jeff’s role puts him in the unique position to discuss the state of active management because he gets to see mutual funds from both the bottom-up, through deep diligence on investment strategies and firms, and top-down, using Morningstar’s data to assess industry-wide trends.  Jeff is one of my favorite myth busters and discuss different variables for assessing active managers and mutual funds, but we also cover his favorite punk rock bands.

Links Referenced

Show Notes

2:04 – (First Question) – What trends in the mutual fund and ETF space have Jeff’s attention today, which Jeff says is the shift towards lower cost, passive investments.

3:48 – Any particular places where we are seeing the most and least flight into passive management from active management and vice versa

5:28 – What catalysts could get people to flow back into active management

8:44 – What are the important things to look for when evaluating active managers

12:31 – Exploring active managers and the amount of money they keep in their own fund typically and how that goes into their evaluation

14:21 – Is there a preference in the type of firms that run funds

15:31 – How does tenure of the manager play into their evaluation

17:24 – Why winning funds can often look like losers

20:45 – Looking at the behavior gap, where the fund is acting in a manner that is more positive than the returns may indicate at the time

23:20 – What will Jeff tell their kids when it comes to investing their money in the future

26:41 – What are the qualitative aspects that Jeff thinks about when evaluating a fund manager

28:53 – How does Jeff weigh holding space and return space as factors when looking at a manage

31:55 – Does Morningstar look at the expense of actively managing a fund over the long term of an investment

32:34 –

33:27 – Looking at moats and how managers build them around their business to help them outperform in the future

36:59 – Building a moat around distribution

41:02 – The most interesting manager Jeff has researched – Primecap Management and why their incentive structure works so well

44:26 – What are active fees going to look like in the future?

49:37 – Why more transparency isn’t always better, (disclaimer: it is very important to Morningstar)

51:52 – Exploring behavior gaps and how they can be avoided

55:45 – Thoughts on the value-growth paradigm

57:49 – Jeff’s most memorable day throughout his career

59:57 – What was the kindest thing that Jeff has done for others and the kindest thing that was done for him.

1:02:37 – Two bands Jeff would encourage people to check out that are a bit under the radar

X – Los Angeles/Wild Gift

Ride – Nowhere

(Referenced) My Bloody Valentine – Loveless

Learn More

We’re using cookies, but you can turn them off in Privacy Settings.  Otherwise, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  Accepting cookies does not mean that we are collecting personal data. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.