Bridge over ocean
29 July 2024 Financial Analysts Journal Volume 80, Issue 4

A Heuristic for Fat-Tailed Stock Market Returns

  1. Ivo Welch
The author proposes a practical correction to assess the probabilities of left-tail events in equity returns. A first-step heuristic Z transformation of –1.25 – log(–Z) results in superior probability assessments for Z statistics lower than –1.
Read the Complete Article in the Financial Analysts Journal CFA Institute Member Content In Practice Member Companion Feature Read brief CFA Institute Member Content
woman reviewing a report
Publish in the Financial Analysts Journal

Interested in having your article published in the Financial Analysts Journal? Submit your article here.

Abstract

Large negative stock and equity portfolio rates of return occur more frequently than they should under the Gaussian normal distribution. They tend to be kurtotic, roughly as if they were drawn from Student T-distributions with 2 to 5 degrees of freedom. A very easy adjustment to help assess the probability of losses is to work with a transformed Z score, Z׳ = −1.25 − log(−Z). For example, one should expect a stock return that is 17 standard deviations below the mean under the empirical distribution as often as one would expect to see a draw that is Z׳ = |–1.25 – log(17) ≈ −4| standard deviations below the mean under the idealized normal distribution.

We're using cookies, but you can turn them off in Privacy Settings. Otherwise, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.