Bridge over ocean
1 March 1994 Financial Analysts Journal Volume 50, Issue 2

The Growth Illusion: The P/E ‘Cost’ of Earnings Growth

  1. Martin L. Leibowitz, PhD
  2. Stanley Kogelman
It is intuitively tempting to view firms with high earnings growth as offering special value. Indeed, standard dividend discount models seem to equate price growth with earnings growth. But a firm can show substantial earnings growth--by increasing earnings retention, for example, or reinvesting at available market rates--without creating a single dollar of extra value for shareholders. The significance of realized earnings growth becomes apparent only after one has determined the "baseline" level of P/E growth (or decline) consistent with the firm's initial prospects and valuation. One must then examine carefully the firm's franchise opportunities--its ability to invest in lines of business that offer more than the market rate of return. The firm's current earnings growth may be "excessive" in relation to the market average, yet not excessive at all given its expected franchise opportunities. High earnings that derive from franchise opportunities already embedded in the firm's P/E reflect management's exploitation of preexisting opportunities. In effect, this exploitation represents a drawdown of the franchise value incorporated in P/E and suggests an inverse relation between realized earnings growth and realized P/E. Only if management has the skill or luck to extend the firm's franchise opportunities beyond those already embedded in the firm's valuation will excess earnings growth represent added value to shareholders.
Read the Complete Article in Financial Analysts Journal Financial Analysts Journal CFA Institute Member Content
Publisher Information
Association for Investment Management and Research 13 pages doi.org/10.2469/faj.v50.n2.36 ISSN/ISBN: 0015-198X

We’re using cookies, but you can turn them off in Privacy Settings.  Otherwise, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  Accepting cookies does not mean that we are collecting personal data. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.