Bridge over ocean
1 November 1985 Financial Analysts Journal Volume 41, Issue 6

Some Evidence on the Value of Dividend Discount Models

  1. Eric H. Sorensen
  2. David A. Williamson, CFA

Systematic use of dividend discount models has the potential to add value to the portfolio management process. Using consensus forecasts of earnings growth, the authors tested four valuation models ranging in complexity from a simple price-earnings ratio model to a three-period dividend discount model. Each model was used to rank 150 stocks from the S&P 400 into five portfolios, and in each case the model’s ranking was borne out by subsequent portfolio return. Furthermore, all the top-ranked portfolios outperformed the market average.

Portfolio returns improved considerably, however, as the complexity of the model used to rank them increased. The top-ranked portfolio from the three-period dividend discount model, for example, had an annual return 3.5 per cent greater than the return on the top-ranked portfolio from the P/E model.

Ability to discriminate between under and overperformance also increased with model complexity. The portfolios ranked best and worst by the P/E method differed in return by 22.26 per cent; this difference increased to 35.63 per cent when the three-period model was used for ranking. Adjustment for risk improved model performance, especially when used in conjunction with the more complex models.

Read the Complete Article in Financial Analysts Journal Financial Analysts Journal CFA Institute Member Content

We’re using cookies, but you can turn them off in Privacy Settings.  Otherwise, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  Accepting cookies does not mean that we are collecting personal data. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.