Bridge over ocean
1 July 1983 Financial Analysts Journal Volume 39, Issue 4

Industry Relative Price-Earnings Ratios as Indicators of Investment Returns

  1. David A. Goodman
  2. John W. Peavy

Do stocks with low price-earnings ratios outperform stocks with high price-earnings ratios? Some tests indicate that low P/E stocks do offer excess returns. Critics of these tests, however, contend that the higher observed returns are attributable, not to the P/E ratios, but to the small firm size and infrequent trading that tend to characterize low P/E stocks.

The authors control for the small firm and infrequent trading effects by including in their tests only frequently traded stocks of companies of a certain size. In addition, they control for another possible bias—the industry effect. Because firms in the same industry tend to cluster in the same relative P/E ranking, detected return differences between P/E groups may be attributable to industry performance, rather than P/E level. This bias is eliminated by using price-earnings relatives (PERs)—the index of the P/E ratio of a stock relative to its industry.

The results indicate that PER is a significant factor related to excess returns. Low PER portfolios tend to outperform high PER portfolios, as well as the sample mean. Furthermore, as PER increases, returns decline consistently.

Read the Complete Article in Financial Analysts Journal Financial Analysts Journal CFA Institute Member Content

We’re using cookies, but you can turn them off in Privacy Settings.  Otherwise, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.  Accepting cookies does not mean that we are collecting personal data. Learn more in our Privacy Policy.