notices - See details
Notices
Enterprising Investor Default Hero Image
27 April 2017 Enterprising Investor Blog

Meditation Tips for Investment Professionals: Focused Awareness

Enterprising Investor Blogs logo thumbnail

Meditation provides investors with many benefits. Below are meditation tips from the newly released Meditation Guide for Investment Professionals, the full version of which is available online for CFA Institute members.

In focused awareness meditation, also known as Zen, practitioners concentrate on one object. The object can be the breath, a candle flame, a white wall, the repetition of a word, a series of words — or mantra — etc. When awareness inevitably strays, meditators return their focus to that object.

In previous articles in this series, I shared general meditation tips and described the open-monitoring form of meditation, which hones our natural state of consciousness known as metacognition, or the awareness of awareness itself.

Focused awareness has much in common with open-monitoring, so some confusion is understandable. But these two forms of meditation are really two sides of the same coin. Open-monitoring practitioners notice the thoughts that come into awareness. They do not scrutinize them but let them pass out of awareness. They then return to being open, aware, and non-attached.

Focused awareness meditators have a singular point of attention. They ignore distractions when they arise and refocus back on the object at the center of the meditation.

Focused Awareness Meditation

What It Is: Focused awareness meditation trains a natural capability of mental functioning: top-down control. What is top-down control? It's our capacity to choose what to think and when to think it. For many of us, top-down control is far removed from our normal, waking state of consciousness wherein random thoughts enter and exit our minds. Some of these thoughts come fully formed, but most are bits and pieces of other thoughts. Focused-awareness seeks to eradicate this noise. In a world that demands intense mental concentration and clarity from investment professionals, focused awareness is critical.

Science has identified four or five major forms of meditation. The fifth form is known as "automatic self-transcending" among its adherents and some researchers. Transcendental meditation is one variety of this form. Like focused awareness, automatic self-transcending requires practitioners to focus on a single thing, in this instance, a word or series of words — a mantra.

Some emerging neuroscientific research demonstrates that automatic self-transcending has distinct effects on practitioners. Specifically, it engages the parts of the brain associated with verbal and motor skills. For our purposes, however, in keeping with other researchers’ work, we classify automatic self-transcending as a sub-form of focused awareness.

Benefits

Focused awareness meditation relieves stress and improves thinking. Experienced focused awareness meditators have better control over their attention: Their minds wander less, and they can choose when and how to think.

Steps

Focused awareness requires the most mental discipline of all the meditation styles. Its practitioners emphasize how critical technique is to achieving the intended goal of disciplined focus.

Below are steps for a generalized focused awareness meditation using breath as the singular object. For convenience, read the steps into your smartphone’s Voice Notes function so you can control the pacing and duration of your meditation.

  • Posture is important — keep your back straight.
  • Beginners: Sit on a cushion or in a chair.
  • If you are sitting on a cushion, use a regular cross-legged position.
  • Your knees should be lower than your seat and point slightly downward.
  • If you are in a chair, keep your feet flat on the ground and your back off of the chair so that it remains straight.
  • Plant your tailbone firmly into the cushion or the chair.
  • Stack all of your vertebrae, one on top of the next, working all the way up from your tailbone.
  • Tuck your chin in slightly.
  • You should be sitting erect as though the crown of your head is pushing upward.
  • Close your mouth and touch your tongue to your palate. As you gain experience, you may place your tongue further back, ideally touching your soft palate. But do not strain the tongue.
  • Place your hands in your lap, with your left hand in your right hand. Make sure that the thumbs are touching, with your hands forming a circle.
  • Relax your shoulder muscles.
  • Keep your eyes slightly open and focused on a point roughly three feet in front of you at about a 45-degree angle.
  • Do not concentrate your eyes on anything in particular. Instead, relax them into a soft focus.
  • To ensure you have the correct posture, move your body from side to side and find the spot where your back feels comfortable.
  • Relax and ease into the posture.
  • Begin to breathe through your nose.
  • Relax your chest so that your abdomen moves as you breathe.
  • As you meditate, target your focus point on a spot about two finger widths below your navel. Sometimes this is known as your center of gravity or your core.
  • Your breath should be nice and easy.
  • Gently exhale all of the air in your lungs.
  • As you breathe, imagine your core drawing the breath into itself, as if it is doing all of the work.
  • Continue breathing this way.
  • Thoughts, emotions, and sensations may interrupt your focus on the breath and your core. Don't follow them. Let them go. Be objective. Do not let them distract you. Let them pass like a breeze on your face. Return the focus to your breathing.
  • Continue for at least 10 minutes.
  • When you are ready, come back by fully opening your eyes.
  • Practice this routinely.

Can focus on any activity lead to a meditative state? Yes, it can. Many experienced meditators find that certain pursuits that concentrate their attention on something simple — household chores, exercise, or creating art, for example — can also result in meditative states. What distinguishes meditation is that the meditative state is an outgrowth of the accompanying activity. In meditation, the activity is designed specifically to develop awareness and mental focus.

If you have experiences with focused awareness meditation, share them in the comments section below.

If you are a CFA Institute member and would like more information or support about meditation, then join our LinkedIn CFA Institute Members Meditation Group.

If you liked this post, don't forget to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.


All posts are the opinion of the author. As such, they should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute or the author's employer.

Image credit: ©Getty Images/Kaligraf

25 Comments

JK
Jim Karpen (not verified)
27th April 2017 | 11:12am

Note that in Transcendental Meditation one uses a mantra, but it's not correct to say that one focuses on the mantra. In fact, one doesn't focus on anything. Instead, the practice takes advantage of the natural tendency of the mind to settle down to quieter states, and ultimately transcend thought altogether. Correct use of the mantra facilitates this. As is sometimes said, one uses the mantra in order to lose it.

JV
Jason Voss, CFA (not verified)
27th April 2017 | 9:47pm

Hi Jim,

Thanks for your comment. In the case of TM, it is normally categorized in the scientific literature as a focused awareness meditation. Some are beginning to carve out a separate space for it as there is emerging neuroscientific evidence that, not surprisingly, those repeating a mantra or thinking of a mantra repeatedly are also activating the part of the brain associated with motor function (i.e. the lips are moving, or one is thinking about moving one's lips). Yes, it is true you do not 'focus' on the meditation, but the point is that if you deviate from the mantra you return your attention to it, hence the word 'focus.'

Yours, in service,

Jason

JK
Jim Karpen (not verified)
28th April 2017 | 11:07am

Thanks, Jason. Would be great if you could point me to research that shows that Transcendental Meditation activates the part of the brain associated with motor function.

JV
Jason Voss, CFA (not verified)
28th April 2017 | 5:06pm

Hi Jim,

I am referring to: Fox, et. al.“Functional Neuroanatomy of Meditation: A Review and Meta Analysis of 78 Functional Neuroimaging Investigations.” Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews. 2016

Note, they refer to TM as "automatic self-transcending" as do a limited number of other researchers.

Yours, in service,

Jason

JK
Jim Karpen (not verified)
29th April 2017 | 6:38am

Thanks so much, Jason. I see they don't include any studies on TM. Probably because there's almost no neuroimaging research on TM. It's all been EEG research. I'm pleased they reference Travis and Shear 2010 and put mantra meditation in a separate category. I like their overall aim and rationale.

JV
Jason Voss, CFA (not verified)
1st May 2017 | 10:06am

Thanks, Jim, for your comments.

S
saijanai (not verified)
30th April 2017 | 8:26am

When one is doing anything, the activity of teh brain's default mode network reduces.

However, when one "does" TM, this is not the case. Note the quotation marks around "does."

TM isn't focused attention. Despite your claim about returning attention to it. In fact, attempting to put into words what happens during TM is detrimental to the process.

What makes TM special is that it isn't special. It is merely normal thinking that somehow, kinda sorta involves something that kinda sorta can be called a mantra (if you squint your eyes really hard)... kinda sorta.

As Maharishi Mahesh Yogi explained to someone: I have taught you nothing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9L_L5dIwc00

S
Suly (not verified)
27th April 2017 | 5:12pm

Thanks for the article Jason. I didn't expect to find this type of content here! Do you have a background in the subject matter or your own personal practice? Thanks again.

JV
Jason Voss, CFA (not verified)
27th April 2017 | 9:50pm

Hi, and thank you for your comment. I have been meditating for about 40 years and have also taught meditation. In addition to authoring CFA Institute's Meditation Guide for Investment Professionals, I also served on the Advisory Board for the Mindful Business Conference in 2016; an honor I shared with the former CEO of Starbucks, folks for Google's SIYLI, the chief operating officer of the U.S. Army, and the retired CEO of the American Psychological Association. Yours, in service,

Jason

S
saijanai (not verified)
27th April 2017 | 8:31pm

Mindfulness and focused awareness meditation disrupt the brain's ability to completely rest. This is measured by activation of the "default mode network," which are the regions of hte brain that become most active when you're not trying to do anything.

While it may *seem* like long term practice of these techniques becomes effortless, in fact, the DMN is STILL disrupted by their practice, and the situation only gets more accute, the longer you have been practicing. This is perceived as "getting better" by people who do these kinds of practices.

TM, on the other hand, doesn't disrupt the activity of the DMN, either in short-term or long-term TMers.

With all three kinds of meditation, your brain's activity outside of meditation starts to resemble the activity found during meditation. This means, that with the first two types, you have less and less ability for the brain to truly relax and wander when it needs to. The quietude is that of someone who is always paying attention but never fully relaxed. Studies have shown that "aha!" moments of creativity become less and less likely with such practices, and to compensate, practitioners get better and paying attention to the details of what they already know.

With TM, on the other hand, the quietude found during TM is that of someone who is fully relaxed. As above, the situation starts to be found outside of meditation. Mind-wandering is always available, as is the ability to pay attention, but mind-wandering creativity is ALSO still available. The result is *balance*, which is not found with the first two practices.

Research on athletes show that they become extremely good at paying attention. However, what sets world champions apart from the also-rans is the ability to let their brains fully relax. The brain-wave patterns of world-champions are naturally very much like those found in long-term TM meditators while the brain-wave patterns of also-rans are far less-so.

For maximum success, it seems obvious that one kind of meditation stands out: the kind that induces changes in the brain similar to what is found naturally in champions, not what is found in the also-rans.